Moral identity, moral functioning, and the development of moral character darcia narvaez and daniel k. This volume examines the psychological, socialrelational, and cultural foundations of the most basic moral commitments. It is thought to be a source of moral motivation linking moral reasoning our judgments about whether. Ricoeur ricoeur 1990 and alasdair macintyre 1981 i argue that selfidentity is morally construed, thus is a concept forming a unity with morality. Principal investigator, ethical leadership seminar day. No one has done more than augusto blasi to elevate the importance of moral self. In response, augusto blasi proposed his selfmodel citation needed that links ideas of moral judgment and action through moral commitment. Augusto blasi, emotions and moral motivation philpapers. Those with moral goals central to the selfconcept are more likely to take moral action, as they feel a greater obligation to do so. A socialcognitive framework for understanding moral functioning 375 karl aquino and dan freeman 18.
Why do some people tend to choose those actions that they consider to be moral while others do not, or not with the same frequency and consistency. Augusto blasi 2005 proposed willpower, integrity, and moral desire as the three essential virtues of moral identity. Moral identity is a concept within moral psychology referring to the importance of morality to a persons identity, typically construed as either a traitlike individual difference, or set of chronically accessible schemas empirical studies show that reasoning and emotion only moderately predicted moral action. No one has done more than augusto blasi to elevate the importance of moral selfidentity for understanding moral behavior. In other words, if a persons selfdefinition is comprised of moral traits and. A theoretical perspective augusto blasi university of massachusettsoston considerable theoretical work has been done in the area of moral reasoning.
In the fields of psychology, philosophy, and education, increasing attention has been paid by researchers and theorists to the concepts of the moral self and moral identity. In the final chapter blasi gives his current conception of moral identity. Recently blasi in press has attempted to provide a psychological account of moral character that builds upon his understanding of moral identity moral character, in his view, has three components. According to blasi 1984, moral selfidentity is constructed on the basis of moral commitments. Moral identity is possible, according to blasi, when the self is constructed or defined by reference to moral categories. It begins by looking at the seminal writings of augusto blasi, whose writings on moral cognition, the development of selfidentity, and moral personality have transformed the research agenda in moral psychology. In the wake of research by augusto blasi on moral motivation blasi, 1983 and peter j. Moral development, self, and identity, by daniel k.
University of notre dame handbook of moral and character. Moral development during the adolescent years psychology essay. Like kohlberg, blasi sets moral values across a gulf from bnonmoralq values and selfinterest. Can quantitative assessment of moral identity be improved. Seminal work by augusto blasi 1983, 2004 suggested that.
Adult development theories and issues in human development. This compartmentalization within ones moral self is known as fragmentationa disintegration of ones life into separate domains that grow more. Roger charles bergman, university of nebraska lincoln. It greatly influenced, for example, augusto blasis writings on moral selfidentity. Those who are motivated will attain a unique moral identity.
Moral identity in adulthood ii abstract past research on moral identity development mostly focused on adolescence and early adulthood. A socialcognitive approach to the moral personality. Hence, the problem of moral action is a question of selfconsistency. We relate ethical leadership incorporating an internalized moral identity to productive deviant workplace behavior. However, little conceptual thinking has been done about the relations between moral cognition and moral action. The moral person is one for whom moral categories or moral notions are central, essential, and important to selfunderstanding. The origins and development of the concepts of moral self and moral identity will be traced through piaget, kohlberg, rest, damon, colby and damon, and blasi. An assembly of international and interdisciplinary scholars influenced by blasis work contributed essays that touch upon his areas of influence, including ego development, cognitive development. Moral identity mediates moral knowledge and practical moral decisions. Catholic identity, encounters through service, and a deeper understanding of interreligious dialogue. Two studies document dogooder derogation the putting down of morally motivated others, by studying the reactions of meat eaters to vegetarians.
Burkes theory of identity control burke, a and using a metaphor of space i formulate the. Part of the moral development and citizenship education book series mora, volume 1. Moral identity is possible, according to blasi, when the self is constructed or defined by reference to moral. Drawing on psychologist augusto blasi s self model, i argue that the notion of identitybased motivation can provide a straightforward story about moral judgments and motivation that takes into account both our mix of intuitions as. Using blasis work as a point of departure, a distinguished interdisciplinary and international group of scholars have contributed essays summarizing their own theoretical and empirical research on these topics. Moral development, self, and identity was written as a celebration a festschrift of the work of augusto blasi, whose work on moral cognition, the development of selfidentity, and personality has greatly enriched the fields of moral psychology. Indeed, it is now widely believed that organizing selfunderstanding around basic moral commitments is crucial to the formation of a moral identity which, in turn, underwrites moral conduct. In three parts, the essays map out the relationship between philosophy and psychology in the study of the moral domain, explore the way the moral point of view is understood within kohlbergs cognitivedevelopmental model, and discuss the place of moral development in terms of various models of personality and decision making.
This study adds the how to the bishops what by exploring augusto blasi s theory of the moral self 1983 as it relates to robert kegans constructivedevelopmental theory 1982. The relevance of leader ethicality has motivated ethical leadership theory. Moral development, self, and identity collects essays by moral development researchers, each responding in a different way to blasi s theories of moral motivation. This study focused on two modes, identity observed and management of identity, and was guided by two main hypotheses. Moral identity, moral functioning, and the development of. Moral identity and the development of moral character university of. In examining the relationship between identity and political action, we probe specifically. Presently working on the issue of the development of the self and identity and their relation to morality.
Some contributors are even moving in directions not contemplated by blasi. Our aim is to take moral identity from its roots in developmental psychology and apply it. In blasi s view, willpower and integrity are two core components of character. In other words, people with a stronger sense of moral identity will be more likely. Moral identity is a construct at the intersection of moral development and identity formation.
Pdf chapter 8 moral identity, moral functioning, and the. The sense of self and identity among adolescents and. Two cognitive approaches to moral conduct, piagets and haans, are then discussed in their positive contributions and in their limitations. Moral identity comes to the fore in bergmans chapter, powers, moshmans, and wren and mendozas. So a festschrift for augusto blasi is a timely undertaking. Ricoeur ricoeur 1990 and alasdair macintyre 1981 i argue that self identity is morally construed, thus is a concept forming a unity with morality. Augusto blasi 1999 this course focuses on the issue of moral character its development and its defense against situational challenges. According to blasi 1984, moral self identity is con.
Drawing on psychologist augusto blasi s self model, i contend that the notion of identitybased motivation can provide a straightforward story about moral judgments and motivation in a way that makes sense of our mix of intuitions. One has a moral identity when one is committed to living out the implications of wholehearted moral commitment. The most discussed and controversial challenge to kohlbergs theory of moral development came from carol gilligan, who developed the idea of an ethic of care that exists alongside an ethic based on rights and justice. As a consequence, little is known about developmental changes in moral identity in the adult years.
In this paper, we emphasize the importance of moral identity for the concept of ethical leadership. Catholic schools as spaces for transformative encounter. Research relating moral reasoning to reallife moral behaviors is summarized, with special attention given to design, measurement, and interpretation problems. It is thought to be a source of moral motivation linking moral reasoning our judgments about whether certain actions are right or wrong to behavior.
The traditional concept of character will be redefined in terms of social cognition and in relation to moral identity. Moral development, self, and identity was written as a celebration a festschrift of the work of augusto blasi, whose work on moral cognition, the development of selfidentity, and personality has greatly enriched the fields of moral psychology, personality, and developmental psychology. Using qualitative empirical data we illustrate the relevance of critical situations, i. Blasi 1984 was concerned to render a better account of. The self and the management of the moral life springerlink. This question has recently become more urgent, because it is now clearer that cognitive developmental theories cannot offer a complete explanation of moral functioning.
The motivation to act morally is a result of moral reasoning and understanding. The moral functioning of mature adults and the possibility of fair moral reasoning 396 augusto blasi 19. Indeed, the work of the anthropologist shweder is an important challenge to moral development in its entirety. Although some scholars although some scholars make a clear distinction between the terms moral self and moral identity to distinguish. Paper presented at the augusto blasi festschrift symposium, association for moral education, vancouver, october 27, 2001.
377 612 338 1074 360 856 48 1397 1457 1118 133 1649 931 442 558 51 798 1563 771 462 496 107 538 524 310 577 659 1496 1242 466 5 70 1183